Overcoming Obstacles

Add Lesson to Calendar

Share

Lesson 5: Making a Choice



objectives

  • Students will recognise that decision making is a process. 

  • Students will collaborate with each other to make a decision about their school. 

  • Students will demonstrate the decision making process and make a personal decision.

materials

  • Butchers paper (Part I) 

  • One copy of the “Make It Easy” activity sheet for each student (Part II)

Starter

3 Minutes

Students pair up and play Charades. Students have 2 minutes to get as many correct responses as possible. Tell students that today they will continue building their confidence and strengthening their skills by making more decisions.

Part I: The Five Steps

10 Minutes

Purpose: Through a review of the steps used to make decisions, students recognise that decision making is a process.

1. Students review the process of decision making.

Guide students in conducting their own review of what they have learned about decision making. Prompt students by suggesting that they do the following:

Think about what they would say if they were going to teach someone who is not in this class how to make a decision.

Look through the activity sheets in their folders to help them recall what they have done in previous sessions.

2. Students outline what they have learned.

Through questions, comments, and a few revisions, guide students to write an outline on the board that identifies these five basic steps of the decision making process:

  1. Define the problem.
  2. Gather any information you may need—ask questions.
  3. Identify options available to you—think of as many as you can.
  4. Weigh the pros and cons of the options and the consequences.
  5. Decide.

3. Students recognise decision making as a process.

Through discussion, encourage students to describe as many details about each of the steps as they can recall. Help students reach a consensus that this outline represents a process that they can follow whenever they need to make a decision.

Ask for a student to make a poster that presents the five steps of the decision making process. Display the poster in the room. 

Part II: What's Best for All?

20 Minutes

Purpose: Students collaborate with each other in using the five steps of the decision making process to make a decision about their school.

1. Students prepare for the activity.

Decide whether you wish to have students work as a class or in smaller groups for this activity. If you prefer to have everyone work together as a class, write a few questions such as the ones below on the board, and have the class choose one question to discuss and make a decision about. Choose topics that are of interest to your students.

If you prefer, divide the class into two or three smaller groups. Keep groups large enough to ensure that a number of opinions will be represented. You might assign each group a question, or list a number of questions on the board and allow each group to choose one.

The following are possible topics/questions that groups can consider:

  • Should the process to elect school leaders be changed?
  • Our school can support only five after-school programs. Which programs should it support?
  • What should be done about students in our school who are caught writing graffiti and committing other acts of vandalism?
  • Should girls and boys be allowed to play on the same sports teams?

2. Students use the decision making process to make a decision.

Distribute copies of the “Make It Easy” activity sheet, and suggest that students use them to organise their thoughts and ideas.

If the class is working in smaller groups, give students a time limit (perhaps 10 minutes) to discuss and make a decision. Try to leave enough time at the end of this activity for each group to share briefly the options they considered as well as their final decision. 

Part III: What's Best for Me?

10 Minutes

Purpose: Students practice using the decision making process to make a personal decision.

1. Students reflect on decisions they are currently dealing with in their own lives.

Explain that students will have the opportunity to make one more decision before they leave class today. Ask them to think about what is happening in their lives. Suggest that they think about relationships with friends, what might happen in the future, or anything else that they need to make a decision about. Or students may want, instead, to reconsider a past decision that had negative consequences.

2. Students work through the decision making process.

Tell students to make their own pro/con lists to help them organise their thoughts. If students need information, suggest that they make a list of questions and write down whom they need to ask. Explain that they have the remainder of the class period to think about options and consequences, and to evaluate the pros and cons for each.

Tell students that they do not need to actually make their decision today—especially if they need to gather information. The goal is to at least start the process.

Conclusion

2 Minutes

Ask students if they think that people who are successful in life are good decision makers. Ask them to explain their answers. Elicit from students the following key points that were taught in this lesson:

  • Use all the steps of the decision making process when making decisions that are important to you: define the problem, gather information if needed, identify options, weigh options and consequences, and decide.
  • The best decisions are thoughtfully made, so take the necessary time to make them.

Student Assessment

  1. List the five steps of the decision making process.
  2. What makes a decision thoughtful?
  3. Write a scenario in which all the steps of the decision making process are used.

Extensions for Lesson 5: Making a Choice

Using Quotations

“Nobody ever did, or ever will, escape the consequences of his choices.” 

Have students create an acronym that will help them remember the five steps of the decision making process (e.g., “CROWD” for “consequences, research, options, weigh choices, decide”).

Addressing Multiple Learning Modes

Have students write about a choice that seemed completely out of their hands. Have them write about available options that might have yielded a different outcome.

Have interested students anonymously address unresolved concerns to “the Source,” as in Lesson 1. 

Writing in Your Journal

Have students write about a recurring choice that’s difficult to make (e.g., withstanding peer pressure to smoke, resisting tempting alternatives to doing homework).

Using Technology

Have students watch a tourism advertisement and discuss in small groups the persuasive techniques that have been used.

Homework

Have students create posters with advice about a choice that could be difficult to follow through on (e.g., saying no to smoking, doing homework daily). They should include three consequences of following (or not following) the advice.

Display the finished posters around the classroom.

Additional Activity

Have students watch their favourite TV show and write about a character’s decision.

Activity Sheet

Using Google Slides, you can customize every Overcoming Obstacles activity sheet in the Elementary, Middle, and High School levels.

Click on the button below to open a link to the Google Slides version of this activity sheet. In order to begin editing the file, you will first need to save a copy of the slide to your Google account. You can do this by selecting “File” and then “Make a Copy.”

If you have any questions or need assistance with our Activity Sheet Customization feature, please contact us at [email protected].


Want to download activity sheets in other languages?

Click the button for activity sheets in Spanish, French, Simplified Chinese, Haitian-Creole, and more!